One Of The Broken by John Carson
Publisher: Amazon Kindle
Genre: Contemporary, Mystery/Suspense/Thriller
Rating: 3 stars
Reviewed by Fern

You can run…but you can never hide from the truth

A man is found murdered in his home, bludgeoned to death. In his hand is a piece from a jigsaw puzzle. Despite being widely liked, someone harboured a deadly grudge.

DCI James Craig, who recently relocated from London to Fife to work with Police Scotland, leads a dedicated team tasked with unraveling the mystery behind the murder and the significance of the puzzling clue left behind. Despite the victim’s seemingly spotless reputation, lingering shadows from his past hint at a possible motive.

As Craig delves into the victim’s history, he uncovers the existence of a sinister alter ego that may have precipitated his demise, and the unsettling realisation that the killer may have more targets in mind.
With time ticking away, Craig races against the clock to identify potential victims before the tranquillity of the area is shattered by further bloodshed.

After the traumatic events that changed DCI James Craig’s world a few months ago, Craig and his wife are finally beginning to settle into a new routine. Back in Fife, Scotland they are trying hard to find a sense of normal again. When Craig is called out onto his first proper investigation, he’s pleased to finally turn his mind onto easier matters – like murder.

I enjoyed this second book in a new series by this author. While the cast of characters isn’t enormous, there are quite a few in the team and periphery around the case. I didn’t struggle to keep everyone in order – but readers who aren’t used to the frequently large cast this author tends to write might find it an effort to keep all the characters clear in their head. I also was quite pleased there was a bit of explanation and a very brief summary of events that led Craig and his wife to where they are right now. The ending to the previous book was literally life shattering for them both and they are both still clearly processing and coming to terms with this outcome and so it would have been quite disjointed I feel without some explanation, so I thought this was handled very well.

That said, I do feel this book can be picked up by itself. I’m wondering if perhaps later books in this series might have a bit too much history and backstory to really leave the option open to read these out of order or just randomly select one and start there, but for this second book I definitely feel readers should be able to comfortably catch up without having to go back to the first.

I also thought it was quite refreshing how the “who” aspect to the villain in this book was shown to the reader fairly early on. This was very much more of a plot and story to solve why the murders occurred and how these events came to be – rather than a “whodunit” style of mystery. While absolutely not uncommon – I really did enjoy this and being able to glimpse snatches from the murder’s perspective and slowly try to piece the puzzle together was really interesting and kept me heavily invested in the story. While I could understand if early unveiling isn’t every reader’s cup of tea, I absolutely felt there was plenty of mystery around why these murders were occurring and how it all connected up together, so I felt it was a lovely and rather refreshing take on a police procedural style of mystery novel.

With the slightly grittier Scottish backdrop and a complex plot I enjoyed this book and am eagerly awaiting the third to be published.