Burnt Island by Kate Rhodes
Publisher: Simon & Schuster UK
Genre: Contemporary, Mystery/Suspense/Thriller
Rating: Three stars
Reviewed by FernINTRUDERS HERE ARE BOUND TO DIE
As the sun sets on St Agnes on bonfire night, a man’s charred body is found on Burnt Island, surrounded by threats in the old Cornish language.
Deputy Chief of Police Ben Kitto has no choice but to ban all travel between the islands, forcing the community of just eighty islanders to remain within reach, while he hunts for the killer. Ben quickly suspects the motive is to rid the island of newcomers who threaten tradition, and when a second fire results in the disappearance of another islander, he only has forty-eight hours before another life is lost . . .
On the tiny Scilly Island of St Agnes moments before the annual Fifth of November fireworks and festivities one of the locals is found burned to death, his charred body a very clear message that a killer looms large amongst the 80 locals. DI Ben Kitto is determined to keep the small community safe, but there are many hidden currents, and he can’t deny the tension looming between the old Cornish ways and the newer incomers.
I have been really enjoying this British Police procedural series revolving around a small group of islands off the Cornwell coastline. While Ben and Eddie – his sergeant – as well as their boss the Chief of Police are all regular characters each book so far in the series had felt very much like a standalone because while the links between the islands are strong and plenty of the locals visit the other islands the core community of each group remains quite discreet. This lets the books feel very much as if they stand alone, because each community is quite distinctive, and this helps keep the stories separate. I am really enjoying this, and I definitely feel readers should feel comfortable starting pretty much anywhere so far in the series.
I thought the plot to this book was very well handled. After Ben begins to investigate it’s quite clear there is no real reason for the victim to have been killed. Instead of feeling random this leads to the fact that there’s something much deeper underlying the plot and I thoroughly enjoyed the investigation looking into what was really going on. I thought this was paced very well, my only small disappointment was how Ben followed through on one thread that was clearly an “easy out” kind of explanation and while I could clearly see why and how he went down this path and the supporting evidence that led him there, I was a bit sad Ben didn’t listen to Eddie or his advice and thoughts and neither did Ben stop to think about how this lead was a bit of a cop out and too pat and easy to be readily believed. In a backhanded way I could see that jumping on believing that the local weirdo was responsible certainly pushed the plot forward and helped develop the tension and pacing, but it felt to me rather like picking on the shy and quiet kid instead of actually looking for the real answer.
With quite a bit of action and a good pace I enjoyed this murder mystery and am growing to be quite a fan of the series as a whole. I’m looking forward to the next story in this series.
